Monday, June 30, 2008

[06.23-27.2008] – Week 3

I am changing the format of my entries to weekly ones. Now that we are three weeks into our ten week internship, the amount of work has steadily increased.
It’s been a very interesting week. The highlight of my week was Thursday, when we observed a merits hearing for an asylum case with Judge Walton. From our training notes, I had the following advised to me by the law clerks: “Judge Walton- (1) mostly does motions to reopen; (2) can come off moody and harsh; (3) his daughter works at Disneyland and he loves baseball; (4) from private practice and very detail oriented; and (5) usually gives cases after he has done a thorough and intensive review.” I didn’t find him moody or harsh at all. He was a little stern on one individual that came in late to his hearing time. But for the matter of asylum, he was very personable. It was interesting to see his personality come out through his presentation in court.
We learned from Judge Tabaddor that asylum is a discretionary form of relief which allows aliens to remain in the United States and apply for residency after one year if they are fleeing persecution in their homeland on account of their race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. These are the stringent categories to qualify for such a high form of relief. Recently, there have been some individuals seeking asylum under the category of “membership of a particular social group”, where the group is defined as females in domestic abusive relationships. In these cases, the persecutor is a domestic partner and usually their home country lacks a reliable form of relief.
Judge Walton informed us that up until 2001, there was one particular case that set the precedence for this matter. In the case Matter of R-A-, 22 I&N Dec. 906, 917 (2001), the Court ruled that “Guatemalan women who have been involved intimately with Guatemalan male companions, who believe that women are to live under male domination” is not a particular social group. Here, the Respondent addressed cultural issues where most Guatemalan women do not legally marry their partners and very few cases are brought into court. Most aggressors in domestic violence cases are detained for a few hours and released upon payment of a fine. Unfortunately, in 2001, the Attorney General pulled the case with intent to review. A decision on the matter has not been made to this day.
In the case we observed on Thursday, the woman was from Guatemala and had been with her partner for over twenty years. She and her partner shared four children. The facts indicate that she shared a common law marriage and were domestic partners; the two were not legally married. (An interesting point here was that her partner was married to another woman who managed to escape his abuse. They never obtained a formal divorce.) The judge stressed the word “domestic” as a word indicating home. Therefore, a dating relationship would not qualify as there is really no common “home” between the two individuals. The judge ruled in favor of the asylum application. I was a little reserved by the decision because she failed to contact the police and I found the Government’s “flood gate” argument credible. The “flood gate” argument surrounds the issue of proceeding cases brought before the Court; now that we allowed one woman to escape into the United States under the asylum relief, it may be likely that women in domestic violence relationships all around the world would escape to the United States. The judge, however, made a good point in rebuttal to this argument. “Just because we’re afraid others may try and use this form of relief, is this enough grounds for us to reject this woman who has displayed credible fear from her domestic partner?” Judge Walton also felt that current reports regarding Guatemala’s new domestic violence prevention programs were too unreliable to predict her future likelihood of receiving help. He held in favor of the petitioner and granted her relief. The other interns and I had a pretty interesting discussion regarding the case we observed.
The rest of the week remained with the motion to reopen and a memo for Judge Bank. The motion to reopen was so confusing but I finally managed to get it to the judge’s desk. I had a tough time finding the statute surrounding service to minors. After much searching I landed upon to 8 C.F.R. 1236.2(a), which requires that service upon a minor be provided “upon the person with whom the incompetent or the minor resides.” See 8 C.F.R. § 1236.2(a); see also 8 C.F.R. § 103.5 (c)(2)(ii). The memo I am now working on is surrounding Attorney Discipline. The judge wants to give the guy a 12-16 month suspension. The research is a little tough but luckily the other clerks have started the memo and I am merely adding cases to support the length of discipline. Did you know there is a difference between suspension and actual suspension? There are several forms of discipline for attorney misconduct. It goes to show that there are some bad lawyers out there. Also, it’s a good note to myself to make sure I stay on top of my game once I get to the practice of law!!
Thank goodness for Friday. I’m a little sad because my favorite judge, Judge Gembacz, is retiring this Friday. He is always filled with laughs and good advice. I never knew my grandfather, but if I could ever ask for one, he would be something like Judge G. I wish him the best!
Picture: My cubie on the 17th floor. We're rotating out next week.
Time Stamp Each Day: 8:00 AM- 4:30PM

Thursday, June 26, 2008

[week 02]




[06.16.2008] – Day Six (Monday)
It’s hard to get to bed early on a Sunday night. I found myself crawling into bed at 2:00am only to arise at 5:15am in total reluctance.
Managed to get to work on time since there was not that much traffic. Came in and finished the last draft of my Motion to Reopen (Project #1) regarding Exceptional Circumstances as an excuse. It ended up being a denial. In the case, Respondent was personally and properly served with the Notice to Appear. Respondent was also verbally notified of the time and place of her hearing and of the consequences of her failure to appear at the scheduled hearing. Therefore, because the Court sent a Notice of Hearing to Respondent’s last known address, the Government met the presumption of effective delivery by mailing a properly addressed, stamped, and deposited notice to the most recent address provided by Respondent. This was determined in Busquets-Ivars v. Ashcroft, 333 F.3d 1008, 1010 (9th Cir. 2003), where there is a presumption of effective delivery if the notice of hearing was “properly addressed; had sufficient postage; and was properly deposited into the mails.” An applicant can be “properly charged with receiving notice, even though he or she did not personally see the mailed document.” Matter of G-Y-R-, 23 I. & N. Dec. 181, 185-186 (BIA 2001). Furthermore, Respondent has provided no evidence, circumstantial or otherwise, to rebut the presumption of effective delivery. Handed it to the judge and we’ll see what she says.
Received another Motion to Reopen (Project #2), but this time it is due to Lack of Notice. There are a lot of holes in this case, but it looks like a denial. The respondent failed to notify the court of her change of address.
Need to look at it more carefully tomorrow. The lack of sleep makes it hard to organize my thoughts.

[06.17.2008] – Day Seven (Tuesday)
I ended up passing out at the library yesterday- on the floor! Not fainting- but somehow I woke up on my arm, on the floor, in middle of a snore (I rhymed!).

I started the day off by hitting the case I received yesterday. In comparing the two applications this individual submitted, it’s interesting to see the sharp discrepancies. In one application she lived in place X, while in the other version she was in place Y. In one her parents are dead; in the other they are alive. It made me wonder, how much would an individual- not native to the United State- risk to get into the U.S.? Would you lie to the judge in hopes that he might believe you? Would you forge documents? It makes me take a moment and consider what I would do in their shoes. As a born and raised Californian girl, I never thought that my citizenship would be something I take for granted. My parents legally immigrated to the United States and I am the eldest daughter born here. I understand what my parents suffered through, in assimilating to a different culture, but they did it the “right way”. It’s an interesting point to ponder. Which side do you place emphasis on- the social perspective, the legal side, or the individual/ humanistic view? I find that the courts are not a place for “bleeding hearts”. It is definitely a place where rational thought and “big picture thinking” are vital.
“The law is the law is the law”, says one judge. It’s unfortunate to learn that there are several cases that come before the Court where an “attorney’s” failure may cost a family their chance to obtain relief. The Government is smart. Through many of the forms that immigrants sign upon entry, there comes a liability that they may never understand till it negatively impacts them.

[06.18.2008] – Day Eight (Wednesday)
Nothing new to report, just continued working on the Motion to Reopen.

[06.19.2008] – Day Nine (Thursday)
This Motion to Reopen ended up being a lot more complicated that I believed it to be. The argument that will be raised here is that Respondent exceeded the number of filings allowed. This is also called a ‘numerical bar’. An alien may file only one motion to reopen and the Court previously denied Respondent’s Motion to Reopen. No exception to the numerical limit applies to this case.
On a side note, in evaluating the circumstance from an outside perspective, it looks like Respondent should have made a claim to bad counsel. Unfortunately she attempted the Motion to Reopen again and it will probably fail.

[06.20.2008] – Day Ten (Friday)
I took the train in today. The LA Metro isn’t too bad, minus a few crazy encounters by homeless individuals on the train.
Aside from that, the highlight of today was another lecture by Judge T. We covered issues surrounding Adjustment of Status. Usually there are three ways for people to enter the United States: (1) family, (2) employment, or (3) the visa lottery (also called the ‘diversity lottery’). Section 201(a) of the Immigration and Naturalization Act (“INA”) describes these methods of entry. Normally people who are outside of the United States would go through something called ‘consular processing’, where they apply in the US but eventually obtain their visa through the U.S. consular officer located in their home country. Adjustment of Status covers those who are already in the United States and wishing to “adjust” their status. It was interesting to learn about section 201 (c) of the INA which has a formula to determine if visas are available for a certain country. India, Mexico and Philippines have certain restrictions set against them in both work-based and family-based settings. The judge covered the process of determining admissibility and some of the exceptions in this area.
YAY! Friday~ the weekend has arrived.

// it was a tough week so there's two photos for this entry.
[image 1] a view of the downtown buildings in Los Angeles.
[image 2] the building i work in, city national bank, over perishing square. currently situated on the 17th floor.
Time Stamp Each Day: 8:00 AM- 4:30PM

Monday, June 9, 2008

[Week 01] And so it begins...

[06.09.2008] – Day One
Today was the first day of a long but exciting summer. It was the first day of my summer 1L experience at the U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) in downtown Los Angeles. I was filled with so much emotion (excitement, fear, concern, etc.) that I tossed and turned all night. My morning started with me falling out of bed and smack onto my head at 4:45 in the morning.

I am one of three interns that have been selected for this summer. The other two, Rob and Stephen, are really nice guys from Missouri and Michigan respectively (I may have mixed those up). Both are rising 3Ls and they have been selected through the Attorney General’s Honor Program. This means that they are paid for their time here. It was a little defeating to learn this, at first, but I am determined to make this experience worth its time and effort. It is not unusual for 1Ls to work for unit instead of pay.

I am commuting from Cerritos, a small suburb of Los Angeles about twenty five minutes away (normal traffic). It requires me to leave my parents’ home at 6:00am. The commute is horrible, but as a native to the area, it met my exact expectations. Today, in anticipation, I arrived an hour too early so it gave me time to walk around and familiarize myself with the area. While at Carl’s Jr., I was approached by a homeless man who was determined that I was named Judy and that I helped solved the space landing conspiracy. It was definitely an interesting way to start the morning.

I met Rob and Stephen in the waiting room area and our head law clerk, Eric Welsh, greeted the three of us. After getting settled in the conference room, we were quickly ushered to Chief Immigration Judge Fong’s courtroom. After a delightful chat, Judge Fong swore us in. We even received commemorative Polaroid’s to take home with us.

The rest of the day was orientation. We learned about the breakdown from the Department of Justice and Department of Homeland Security. The attorneys from the Department of Homeland Security initiate the cases. In our specific department, EOIR, there are two subsections- the Board of Immigration Appeals and the Office of Chief Immigration Courts. It was interesting to hear the different duties we would cover. Essentially, we would be writing the judicial opinions for approximately twenty six judges. We are assigned to one law clerk and work to look up the cases and compose the final work for the judges. In many instances, we are allowed some discretion to approve or deny the case. This responsibility is a little terrifying but I am sure we will receive a lot of guidance.

At the end of the day, we watched a few of the required videos on Sexual Harassment, Work Place Safety, etc. and had a roundtable discussion with all the law clerks. The law clerks shared the particularities of each judge. Some have very strict expectations with grammar and punctuation; others are more lax in their approach. It should be an interesting week! Tomorrow will be even more difficult because I also have summer school class on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays at Loyola Law School near by. Whew! Here’s to one day down.

[06.10.2008] – Day Two
Today we started the day off watching Judge Tabaddor in her Master Calendar proceedings. It was exciting to be in court and watch everything come alive!

The Master Calendar proceedings are the first stage of the in-court process. The respondents have been served with a Notice to Appear by the Department of Homeland Security and have received a list of their charges. Most have been charged with removability pursuant to section 237(a)(1)(B) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. Simply- they are here in the U.S. without status.

Just by listening to the proceedings, we learned about various aspects of the motions we would soon read. Generally, the respondents will concede to the charges. Other forms of relief come under various acts, such as the Nicaraguan and Central American Relief Act (NACARA).

We continued our court observations in Judge Gembaez’ courtroom after lunch. His calendar was for merits hearing. This is the stage after the Master Calendar (assuming no additional petitions have been added), where the judge listens to the testimony and evidence available. This will help them come up with their final opinion.

The quality of attorneys is appalling! Apparently, many of the attorneys that appear on behalf of the respondents are not certified in California. During our observation, there were several attorneys that would have definitely failed Lawyering Skills I. One attorney came in, looking like he had a long night of drinking, and he had nothing to present to the judge. What was worse- he didn’t realize his client had a wife with a pending asylum application! There are many war stories to keep you fascinated. The rules of the court are very lax in immigration, so you will see interesting people from time to time. Compared the attorneys coming from the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) department in the Department of Homeland Security, these attorneys appear less groomed. On the other hand, the ICE attorneys are amazing to watch. They are well learned and very professional. It is fun to watch the proceedings in court.

One thing to note, the courtroom benches are really uncomfortable! Otherwise, it was really fascinating to be in the court. Off to class!

[06.11.2008] – Day Three
After my first full day of work and class, I realized that this is going to be a long summer. Class at Loyola ends at 9:00pm and I have to really muster up my energy to get home and in bed early.

Today we continued with our courtroom observations. First, we logged into CASE, the online system of tracking case information. Then we headed to Judge Muñoz’ courtroom to watch another merits hearing. Again, the attorneys made the morning very interesting. The first attorney lost his temper in court and refused to proceed. He even asked the judge to recuse herself from the case! Apparently, he is known for putting on an act in the courtroom to later take the case to appeals and claim that his clients did not have their rights met.

The second half of the day was a lecture by Eric regarding the substantive law. There are two stages in the process: (1) the removal phase, and (2) the relief stage. We learned about much of the history such as the 1996 Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act. (IIRAIRA). Many changes were enforced under this Act.

There is a lot of background to learn, in order to properly assess each case. Whew! Off to class!.

[06.12.2008] – Day Four
Today we received our first case and our desk assignment! We each received a Motion to Reopen. Luckily there are many documents to help direct us in the right way. My case is regarding a man who missed his hearing due to acute Bronchitis. He failed to notify the court and provided very little documentation. His failure to appear and his concession to charges now places him subject to removability. Unfortunately, I think we have to deny this case which also abandons his asylum application. He did not have much to argue his excuse from court.

Later , we had a brown bag luncheon with Judge Tabaddor. She is an amazing judge. She is very young and very sharp. She lectured on the background of assessing asylum cases. There are many guidelines for an application for asylum and a lot to understand in this area. I realized, after watching a few merits hearing, it is hard to separate heart from mind. Many sob stories enter the court but you have to stick by the law. It must be difficult to send someone home.

[06.13.2008] – Day Five
I survived the week! I came in and finished up my Motion to Reopen. We then had an early discussion with Judge Travieso regarding Cancellation of Removal. This is the last attempt, available to respondents, to stay in the United States. There are many sections in the Immigration and Naturalization Act (INA) that cover Cancellations. There are four major components to obtain cancellation: (i) continuous presence in the United States, (ii) good moral character, (iii) not convicted under § 212(a)(2), § 237 (a)(2), or § 237 (a) (3), and (iv) judicial digression. It is really fascinating to learn all these new laws that come into play in the courtroom.

We spent the rest of the day working and finishing up our memos. I’m all done for the week! One week down and nine more to go. Let the weekend begin!


Time Stamp Each Day:
8:00 AM- 4:30PM