Saturday, July 19, 2008

[07.14- 07.018.2008] – Week 6


I am submitting this paper a little early because I have a final exam on Monday. Whew! I survived the summer school class balance with my internship. It was definitely an arduous summer. I underestimated the commute, as well as the balance needed between a class on a different campus and an internship. I hope these next few weeks will be a little easier, but I still have a lot of things on my list to manage. Unfortunately, since I will not be reporting in to work on Monday, I am writing this without the aid of the research I performed. I completed the other assignments and received a new assignment for a Motion to Reopen, based upon the exigent circumstance of ineffective counsel. It is a very interesting case.

Respondent, in the present case, entered the United States about 1985. Similar to many Mexican natives and citizens that come to our courts, Respondent entered without being admitted or paroled by the Immigration Officer and was illegal in the United States. Upon the advice of a friend, he hired a notario (also known as an immigration consultant). There are many Motions to Reopen because of situations involving notarios. In many countries, a person who carries the title of notario is authorized to provide legal services similar to those performed by a transactional lawyer in the United States. These notaries undergo extensive education and training in their field to earn the coveted title of notary in their country. While a licensed notario in Mexico may be competent to dispense legal advice and to provide legal services under Mexican law, a notary in the United States has no such competency or authorization. I have some understanding of this, because I am a certified California Notary. In the US, a “notary” or “notary public” is appointed by the state government to witness and verify the identity of a person signing a document and to administer oaths. A notary is not qualified to give legal advice and qualifications are gained through a short training course and little more. If only law school were that simple!

Even though one falsely relies on a notario, the burden still remains on the respondent. Immigration Judges will look at each case based upon its given circumstances. For example, if a notario falsely purports that they are an attorney, this will be a stronger claim for reopening than one who knows that the notario is not licensed to practice law. Also, there are several administrative steps that need to be followed, also called Lozada requirements. Under Matter of Lozada, 19 I. & N. Dec. 637 (BIA 1988), an applicant who claims ineffective assistance of counsel must submit (1) an affidavit setting forth in detail the agreement with former counsel concerning what action would be taken and what counsel did or did not represent in this regard; (2) proof that the applicant notified former counsel of the allegations of ineffective assistance and allowed counsel an opportunity to respond; and (3) if a violation of ethical or legal responsibilities is claimed, a statement as to whether the applicant has filed a complaint regarding counsel’s conduct with the appropriate disciplinary authorities and,

if a complaint has not been filed, an explanation for not doing so. Lozada, 19 I. & N. Dec. at 639. In our present case, Respondent waited nine years before filing his Motion to Reopen and took no actions until now, nine years after the removal order!

There are a few other problems in the present case. Respondent claims that he was present in the court house but was afraid to enter the room in fear that the judge would be mad at him. As you can probably assume, this is not a strong claim to make in support for a motion. Furthermore, a recent case decision, Hernandez v. Mukasey, 524 F.3d 1014 (2008), the court held that the reliance on the deficient advice of a non-attorney immigration consultant could not support a claim for deprivation of their Fifth Amendment due process right to competent representation. Their petition was denied. This will probably lead the arguments in my case. The outline of the decision to this motion covers (1) the untimely filing of Respondent’s Motion to Reopen, and (2) the insufficient claim for ineffective assistance as viewed under the Hernandez case. This Motion to Reopen will be denied.

We have passed the half way mark for the internship! I look forward to my experiences this fall at the San Diego County Office of the Public Defender. I seem to be pulled toward government work that plays an integral part in the minority communities. Back to studying for my final! So close!

Time Stamp Each Day: 8:00 AM- 4:30PM

[photo: dinner of law school champions. studying for my final at loyola.]

[07.07- 07.011.2008] – Week 5

I have to admit that I’m struggling with the balance between the last weeks of class and my internship. It seems like my evening class is picking up pace and I am assigned to a pretty difficult project at work. It’s hard not to duplicate work when you’re reviewing something that is completely different and unfamiliar to the prior assignments.

This week was spent working on a new assignment that my attorney advisor, Tara, thought would be a little different. I found it to be very different and a little difficult, but interesting nonetheless. The case I have before me is in relation to the Nicaraguan Adjustment and Central American Relief Act (“NACARA”). Section 203 of NACARA provide that certain Guatemalans, Salvadorans and nationals of former Soviet bloc countries are eligible to apply for suspension of deportation or special rule cancellation of removal under standards similar to those that existed for suspension of deportation prior to the enactment of the September 1996 immigration law. I learned that 1996 was a big year of reform for much of the existing immigration law. It mostly became stricter in its requirements.

The case features a Respondent, who is a citizen and national of El Salvador. He entered the United States back in 1985 and applied several time after his entry for asylum, which was rejected on the merits, and for NACARA. Unfortunately, by the time that his NACARA application hit the desks of the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), Respondent was convicted and sentenced for Penal Code 273.5(A), which involved corporal injury upon a spouse. This was his only conviction and from view of the sentence, it seemed relatively minor. He was sentenced to 36 months of probation, including 30 days in jail or 20 days Cal Trans in lieu of jail time, and various fines. The problem is that this specific type of conviction is generally considered a felony and falls under the category of “Crimes of Moral Turpitude” and affects his eligibility for NACARA.

A Salvadoran is eligible for Special Rule Cancellation of Removal under Section 203 of NACARA, if he has not been convicted of an aggravated felony and is either a registered ABC class member who has not been apprehended at the time of entry after December 19, 1990, or he filed an asylum application on or before April 1, 1990. 8 C.F.R. § 1240.61(a) (2007). The alien must establish that:

(1) he is not inadmissible under section 212(a)(2) or (3) or deportable under section 237(a)(2), (3), or (4) of the Act;

(2) he has been physically present in the United States for a continuous period of 7 years immediately preceding the date the application was filed;

(3) he has been a person of good moral character during the required period of continuous physical presence; and

(4) his removal from the United States would result in extreme hardship to himself or to his spouse, parent, or child, who is a United States citizen or an alien lawfully admitted for permanent residence.

8 C.F.R. § 1240.66(b).

In fortune for Respondent, California is unique in its approach to PC 273.5(A) convictions, and is something called a “wobbler”. Because the conviction may be punishable by either, imprisonment in a state prison, a felony, or imprisonment in the county jail for not more than one year, a misdemeanor, it is a “wobbler” offense. See Garcia-Lopez, 334 F.3d 840, 844-85 (9th Cir. 2003); see also Cal. Penal Code § 17(b). Where the offense is a “wobbler”, it is regarded as a felony for every purpose until judgment. U.S. v. Robinson, 967 F.2d 287, 293 (9th Cir. 1992). “After a judgment imposing a punishment other than imprisonment in the state prison”, such an offense is regarded as a misdemeanor.” Cal. Penal Code § 17(b)(1). I have to make this specific argument that because he had only one conviction and ended up serving community service in lieu of jail time, he may fall under the petty offense exception. This will help him in the argument for not being inadmissible and for being a person of good moral character. It’s funny because one factor of evidence to show his “good moral character” is because he paid his taxes every year and went to school to achieve his English-as-a-Second-Language degree from a local adult school. It goes to show that you should stay in school and pay your taxes! (Oh, and not hit your spouse).

I have only a week remaining till my final at Loyola. I hope I can hang in there till then!

[Time Stamp Each Day: 8:00 AM- 4:30PM]

[image: surprise flowers sent by my awesome and supportive bf in san diego- to spruce up my little corner that shares a wall with the floor potty.]

[06.30- 07.03.2008] – Week 4

This was a short week and relatively uneventful. Thank goodness for one holiday! Too bad that my long weekend will be spent in the bowels of some law library, catching up criminal procedure.

I finished the memo and received one more assignment. This will be my last assignment under Megan. Next week, we’re not only switching seat locations (I get moved into a makeshift desk in the library) but we also change Clerk Supervisors. Next week, I will be under Tara. Both Megan and Tara were the initial interviewers for this position. I really like them both.

The last Motion to Reopen under Megan is interesting and it raises some issues that are still unresolved in the emerging immigration laws. In this Motion, Respondents are a family of six- two parents and four dependent children. The family entered the United States at or near San Ysidro, California back in 1985.

Unfortunately they were not admitted or paroled after inspection by an Immigration Officer and therefore are being charged with removability pursuant to section 212(a)(6)(A)(i) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. Basically it provides that Respondents were present in the United States without being admitted or paroled, or arrived in the United States at a time or place other than designated by the Attorney General.

This, however, isn’t where the problem starts. Back in 1997, the family was granted voluntary departure. This meant that the family “volunteered” that they would leave the United States, rather than be removed, and then reapply properly to enter the United States. In essence, the family would not receive a mark to their name and would not have problems with their application process if they followed the procedures. The downside to this- as with many families from India, Philippines, or Mexico- is that it is a very extended and arduous process to enter the United States with non-work related petitions. The Respondents were from Mexico, and the United States Customs and Immigration Services (USCIS) Visa Bulletin reports the dates are current as up to July 1992. This means that the USCIS is processing cases that have been filed on or before 1992. That’s 16 years ago! What makes this particular case worse is their alleged reasoning as to why they chose to disobey their order for voluntary departure.

Through my experience here, it’s interesting to learn what different claim options are truly available to the families. The attorney for the Respondents in this case chose to file a Motion to Reopen based on Exceptional Circumstances. This was a bad choice for the attorney in my opinion. The Motion alleges that the lead Respondent was under a lot of stress due to a “notario”, that falsely informed the family that they did not need to comply with the order for voluntary departure because of a mentally disabled son. Rather than focus on the “mental distress” factor, the Respondents may have had a better argument with ineffective assistance. Exceptional circumstances refer to situations beyond the respondent’s control, such as serious illness of the respondent or serious illness or death of the spouse, child, or parent of the respondent, but not including less compelling circumstances. See INA § 240(e)1)(1). In determining whether a respondent’s absence was due to “exceptional circumstances”, the Court must look at the “totality of the circumstances.” See Matter of W-F-, 21 I. & N. Dec. 503 (BIA 1996); Matter of Shaar, 21 I. & N. Dec. 541 (BIA 1996). Specifically, the Court must look to the particularized facts presented in the case. See Singh v. INS, 213 F.3d 1050 (9th Cir. 2000) (citing Sharma v. INS, 89 F.3d 545 (9th Cir. 1996)). The Respondent does not qualify under this definition, so this is probably a denial.

The part that makes it very interesting is considering the “punishment” that will arise, and placing this in the perspective of the dependent children. The family, since they have not complied with their order for voluntary departure, will now be barred from entering the United States for ten years. This means no trips into the United States, even for travel or pleasure. No more Disneyland or favorite American restaurant, etc. Taken in light of the children, I feel that this is a very significant issue that policy will soon need to address. The children have established themselves in schools, in after-school activities (such as sports or art classes), with certain friends and community surroundings. They will now be ripped from these roots. It seems problematic that the children should need to displace themselves and suffer under the ten year bar. It will be interesting to see what policy evolves to address the issue of immigrant children.

On a side note to this issue, there is light of some action to deal with juvenile immigrant children. In the Los Angeles Times, they addressed the issue of young illegal immigrants losing sanctuary in San Francisco. San Francisco (a place very close to my heart) is considered “California’s best-known sanctuary city, a haven for illegal immigrants.” Here the article described how for nearly a generation, the city had been escorting convicted juvenile offenders back to their home countries at the city’s expense. At least- until they were caught in Houston. When the city started sending the juveniles to San Bernadino County to unsecured group homes, the residents around the group homes started to voice their concern. Eight convicted juvenile drug dealers simply walked out of the group home. There is a note on policy to be created in how to deal with these children, and it may set precedence for other children/ family / immigration law hybrid cases in California.

Immigration law has so far proved to be very interesting in seeing its impact on various social relationships- especially when it comes to families.

[Time Stamp Each Day: 8:00 AM- 4:30PM]

[image: my new little makeshift desk in the corner of the library. sadness.]