Monday, June 30, 2008

[06.23-27.2008] – Week 3

I am changing the format of my entries to weekly ones. Now that we are three weeks into our ten week internship, the amount of work has steadily increased.
It’s been a very interesting week. The highlight of my week was Thursday, when we observed a merits hearing for an asylum case with Judge Walton. From our training notes, I had the following advised to me by the law clerks: “Judge Walton- (1) mostly does motions to reopen; (2) can come off moody and harsh; (3) his daughter works at Disneyland and he loves baseball; (4) from private practice and very detail oriented; and (5) usually gives cases after he has done a thorough and intensive review.” I didn’t find him moody or harsh at all. He was a little stern on one individual that came in late to his hearing time. But for the matter of asylum, he was very personable. It was interesting to see his personality come out through his presentation in court.
We learned from Judge Tabaddor that asylum is a discretionary form of relief which allows aliens to remain in the United States and apply for residency after one year if they are fleeing persecution in their homeland on account of their race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. These are the stringent categories to qualify for such a high form of relief. Recently, there have been some individuals seeking asylum under the category of “membership of a particular social group”, where the group is defined as females in domestic abusive relationships. In these cases, the persecutor is a domestic partner and usually their home country lacks a reliable form of relief.
Judge Walton informed us that up until 2001, there was one particular case that set the precedence for this matter. In the case Matter of R-A-, 22 I&N Dec. 906, 917 (2001), the Court ruled that “Guatemalan women who have been involved intimately with Guatemalan male companions, who believe that women are to live under male domination” is not a particular social group. Here, the Respondent addressed cultural issues where most Guatemalan women do not legally marry their partners and very few cases are brought into court. Most aggressors in domestic violence cases are detained for a few hours and released upon payment of a fine. Unfortunately, in 2001, the Attorney General pulled the case with intent to review. A decision on the matter has not been made to this day.
In the case we observed on Thursday, the woman was from Guatemala and had been with her partner for over twenty years. She and her partner shared four children. The facts indicate that she shared a common law marriage and were domestic partners; the two were not legally married. (An interesting point here was that her partner was married to another woman who managed to escape his abuse. They never obtained a formal divorce.) The judge stressed the word “domestic” as a word indicating home. Therefore, a dating relationship would not qualify as there is really no common “home” between the two individuals. The judge ruled in favor of the asylum application. I was a little reserved by the decision because she failed to contact the police and I found the Government’s “flood gate” argument credible. The “flood gate” argument surrounds the issue of proceeding cases brought before the Court; now that we allowed one woman to escape into the United States under the asylum relief, it may be likely that women in domestic violence relationships all around the world would escape to the United States. The judge, however, made a good point in rebuttal to this argument. “Just because we’re afraid others may try and use this form of relief, is this enough grounds for us to reject this woman who has displayed credible fear from her domestic partner?” Judge Walton also felt that current reports regarding Guatemala’s new domestic violence prevention programs were too unreliable to predict her future likelihood of receiving help. He held in favor of the petitioner and granted her relief. The other interns and I had a pretty interesting discussion regarding the case we observed.
The rest of the week remained with the motion to reopen and a memo for Judge Bank. The motion to reopen was so confusing but I finally managed to get it to the judge’s desk. I had a tough time finding the statute surrounding service to minors. After much searching I landed upon to 8 C.F.R. 1236.2(a), which requires that service upon a minor be provided “upon the person with whom the incompetent or the minor resides.” See 8 C.F.R. § 1236.2(a); see also 8 C.F.R. § 103.5 (c)(2)(ii). The memo I am now working on is surrounding Attorney Discipline. The judge wants to give the guy a 12-16 month suspension. The research is a little tough but luckily the other clerks have started the memo and I am merely adding cases to support the length of discipline. Did you know there is a difference between suspension and actual suspension? There are several forms of discipline for attorney misconduct. It goes to show that there are some bad lawyers out there. Also, it’s a good note to myself to make sure I stay on top of my game once I get to the practice of law!!
Thank goodness for Friday. I’m a little sad because my favorite judge, Judge Gembacz, is retiring this Friday. He is always filled with laughs and good advice. I never knew my grandfather, but if I could ever ask for one, he would be something like Judge G. I wish him the best!
Picture: My cubie on the 17th floor. We're rotating out next week.
Time Stamp Each Day: 8:00 AM- 4:30PM

1 comment:

natech said...

Nice post! Enjoyed reading this. I have this on my reader. :-) Didn't know that you never knew your grandfather. Judge G. is the one that you had a pic on your facebook?