[06.09.2008] – Day OneToday was the first day of a long but exciting summer. It was the first day of my summer 1L experience at the U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) in downtown Los Angeles. I was filled with so much emotion (excitement, fear, concern, etc.) that I tossed and turned all night. My morning started with me falling out of bed and smack onto my head at 4:45 in the morning.
I am one of three interns that have been selected for this summer. The other two, Rob and Stephen, are really nice guys from Missouri and Michigan respectively (I may have mixed those up). Both are rising 3Ls and they have been selected through the Attorney General’s Honor Program. This means that they are paid for their time here. It was a little defeating to learn this, at first, but I am determined to make this experience worth its time and effort. It is not unusual for 1Ls to work for unit instead of pay.
I am commuting from Cerritos, a small suburb of Los Angeles about twenty five minutes away (normal traffic). It requires me to leave my parents’ home at 6:00am. The commute is horrible, but as a native to the area, it met my exact expectations. Today, in anticipation, I arrived an hour too early so it gave me time to walk around and familiarize myself with the area. While at Carl’s Jr., I was approached by a homeless man who was determined that I was named Judy and that I helped solved the space landing conspiracy. It was definitely an interesting way to start the morning.
I met Rob and Stephen in the waiting room area and our head law clerk, Eric Welsh, greeted the three of us. After getting settled in the conference room, we were quickly ushered to Chief Immigration Judge Fong’s courtroom. After a delightful chat, Judge Fong swore us in. We even received commemorative Polaroid’s to take home with us.
The rest of the day was orientation. We learned about the breakdown from the Department of Justice and Department of Homeland Security. The attorneys from the Department of Homeland Security initiate the cases. In our specific department, EOIR, there are two subsections- the Board of Immigration Appeals and the Office of Chief Immigration Courts. It was interesting to hear the different duties we would cover. Essentially, we would be writing the judicial opinions for approximately twenty six judges. We are assigned to one law clerk and work to look up the cases and compose the final work for the judges. In many instances, we are allowed some discretion to approve or deny the case. This responsibility is a little terrifying but I am sure we will receive a lot of guidance.
At the end of the day, we watched a few of the required videos on Sexual Harassment, Work Place Safety, etc. and had a roundtable discussion with all the law clerks. The law clerks shared the particularities of each judge. Some have very strict expectations with grammar and punctuation; others are more lax in their approach. It should be an interesting week! Tomorrow will be even more difficult because I also have summer school class on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays at Loyola Law School near by. Whew! Here’s to one day down.
[06.10.2008] – Day Two
Today we started the day off watching Judge Tabaddor in her Master Calendar proceedings. It was exciting to be in court and watch everything come alive!
The Master Calendar proceedings are the first stage of the in-court process. The respondents have been served with a Notice to Appear by the Department of Homeland Security and have received a list of their charges. Most have been charged with removability pursuant to section 237(a)(1)(B) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. Simply- they are here in the U.S. without status.
Just by listening to the proceedings, we learned about various aspects of the motions we would soon read. Generally, the respondents will concede to the charges. Other forms of relief come under various acts, such as the Nicaraguan and Central American Relief Act (NACARA).
We continued our court observations in Judge Gembaez’ courtroom after lunch. His calendar was for merits hearing. This is the stage after the Master Calendar (assuming no additional petitions have been added), where the judge listens to the testimony and evidence available. This will help them come up with their final opinion.
The quality of attorneys is appalling! Apparently, many of the attorneys that appear on behalf of the respondents are not certified in California. During our observation, there were several attorneys that would have definitely failed Lawyering Skills I. One attorney came in, looking like he had a long night of drinking, and he had nothing to present to the judge. What was worse- he didn’t realize his client had a wife with a pending asylum application! There are many war stories to keep you fascinated. The rules of the court are very lax in immigration, so you will see interesting people from time to time. Compared the attorneys coming from the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) department in the Department of Homeland Security, these attorneys appear less groomed. On the other hand, the ICE attorneys are amazing to watch. They are well learned and very professional. It is fun to watch the proceedings in court.
One thing to note, the courtroom benches are really uncomfortable! Otherwise, it was really fascinating to be in the court. Off to class!
[06.11.2008] – Day Three
After my first full day of work and class, I realized that this is going to be a long summer. Class at Loyola ends at 9:00pm and I have to really muster up my energy to get home and in bed early.
Today we continued with our courtroom observations. First, we logged into CASE, the online system of tracking case information. Then we headed to Judge Muñoz’ courtroom to watch another merits hearing. Again, the attorneys made the morning very interesting. The first attorney lost his temper in court and refused to proceed. He even asked the judge to recuse herself from the case! Apparently, he is known for putting on an act in the courtroom to later take the case to appeals and claim that his clients did not have their rights met.
The second half of the day was a lecture by Eric regarding the substantive law. There are two stages in the process: (1) the removal phase, and (2) the relief stage. We learned about much of the history such as the 1996 Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act. (IIRAIRA). Many changes were enforced under this Act.
There is a lot of background to learn, in order to properly assess each case. Whew! Off to class!.
[06.12.2008] – Day Four
Today we received our first case and our desk assignment! We each received a Motion to Reopen. Luckily there are many documents to help direct us in the right way. My case is regarding a man who missed his hearing due to acute Bronchitis. He failed to notify the court and provided very little documentation. His failure to appear and his concession to charges now places him subject to removability. Unfortunately, I think we have to deny this case which also abandons his asylum application. He did not have much to argue his excuse from court.
Later , we had a brown bag luncheon with Judge Tabaddor. She is an amazing judge. She is very young and very sharp. She lectured on the background of assessing asylum cases. There are many guidelines for an application for asylum and a lot to understand in this area. I realized, after watching a few merits hearing, it is hard to separate heart from mind. Many sob stories enter the court but you have to stick by the law. It must be difficult to send someone home.
[06.13.2008] – Day Five
I survived the week! I came in and finished up my Motion to Reopen. We then had an early discussion with Judge Travieso regarding Cancellation of Removal. This is the last attempt, available to respondents, to stay in the United States. There are many sections in the Immigration and Naturalization Act (INA) that cover Cancellations. There are four major components to obtain cancellation: (i) continuous presence in the United States, (ii) good moral character, (iii) not convicted under § 212(a)(2), § 237 (a)(2), or § 237 (a) (3), and (iv) judicial digression. It is really fascinating to learn all these new laws that come into play in the courtroom.
We spent the rest of the day working and finishing up our memos. I’m all done for the week! One week down and nine more to go. Let the weekend begin!
Time Stamp Each Day:
8:00 AM- 4:30PM
2 comments:
Oh wow, you're starting your work blog. I should do that. Thanks for the inspiration. We've kind of known each other for a while now. Ha, cool. :-) Keep it up!
Hi. I found your blog by searching for "immigration judge" and 1L. I am a 1L who wants to work for an immigration judge this summer, but cannot find out how to apply. The EOIR says it's only for 2L and 3L summers. Reading through what you said, it seems that perhaps 1Ls can do it, but they don't get paid. Do you suppose that's how it works? How did you find/apply for/land your clerkship? If you have any time to answer that question, I will be very grateful. Thanks, John
johnbenjaminmoore@gmail.com
Post a Comment