Saturday, July 19, 2008

[07.14- 07.018.2008] – Week 6


I am submitting this paper a little early because I have a final exam on Monday. Whew! I survived the summer school class balance with my internship. It was definitely an arduous summer. I underestimated the commute, as well as the balance needed between a class on a different campus and an internship. I hope these next few weeks will be a little easier, but I still have a lot of things on my list to manage. Unfortunately, since I will not be reporting in to work on Monday, I am writing this without the aid of the research I performed. I completed the other assignments and received a new assignment for a Motion to Reopen, based upon the exigent circumstance of ineffective counsel. It is a very interesting case.

Respondent, in the present case, entered the United States about 1985. Similar to many Mexican natives and citizens that come to our courts, Respondent entered without being admitted or paroled by the Immigration Officer and was illegal in the United States. Upon the advice of a friend, he hired a notario (also known as an immigration consultant). There are many Motions to Reopen because of situations involving notarios. In many countries, a person who carries the title of notario is authorized to provide legal services similar to those performed by a transactional lawyer in the United States. These notaries undergo extensive education and training in their field to earn the coveted title of notary in their country. While a licensed notario in Mexico may be competent to dispense legal advice and to provide legal services under Mexican law, a notary in the United States has no such competency or authorization. I have some understanding of this, because I am a certified California Notary. In the US, a “notary” or “notary public” is appointed by the state government to witness and verify the identity of a person signing a document and to administer oaths. A notary is not qualified to give legal advice and qualifications are gained through a short training course and little more. If only law school were that simple!

Even though one falsely relies on a notario, the burden still remains on the respondent. Immigration Judges will look at each case based upon its given circumstances. For example, if a notario falsely purports that they are an attorney, this will be a stronger claim for reopening than one who knows that the notario is not licensed to practice law. Also, there are several administrative steps that need to be followed, also called Lozada requirements. Under Matter of Lozada, 19 I. & N. Dec. 637 (BIA 1988), an applicant who claims ineffective assistance of counsel must submit (1) an affidavit setting forth in detail the agreement with former counsel concerning what action would be taken and what counsel did or did not represent in this regard; (2) proof that the applicant notified former counsel of the allegations of ineffective assistance and allowed counsel an opportunity to respond; and (3) if a violation of ethical or legal responsibilities is claimed, a statement as to whether the applicant has filed a complaint regarding counsel’s conduct with the appropriate disciplinary authorities and,

if a complaint has not been filed, an explanation for not doing so. Lozada, 19 I. & N. Dec. at 639. In our present case, Respondent waited nine years before filing his Motion to Reopen and took no actions until now, nine years after the removal order!

There are a few other problems in the present case. Respondent claims that he was present in the court house but was afraid to enter the room in fear that the judge would be mad at him. As you can probably assume, this is not a strong claim to make in support for a motion. Furthermore, a recent case decision, Hernandez v. Mukasey, 524 F.3d 1014 (2008), the court held that the reliance on the deficient advice of a non-attorney immigration consultant could not support a claim for deprivation of their Fifth Amendment due process right to competent representation. Their petition was denied. This will probably lead the arguments in my case. The outline of the decision to this motion covers (1) the untimely filing of Respondent’s Motion to Reopen, and (2) the insufficient claim for ineffective assistance as viewed under the Hernandez case. This Motion to Reopen will be denied.

We have passed the half way mark for the internship! I look forward to my experiences this fall at the San Diego County Office of the Public Defender. I seem to be pulled toward government work that plays an integral part in the minority communities. Back to studying for my final! So close!

Time Stamp Each Day: 8:00 AM- 4:30PM

[photo: dinner of law school champions. studying for my final at loyola.]

No comments: